Sunday, October 28, 2007

STORY OF SALT - FEAR AND FAVOUR

The Food Standards Agency has set a target of reducing the average salt consumption of adults to 6g a day by 2010. The Agency’s advice on salt intake for adults and children is underpinned by the recommendations of the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN). SACN is an independent expert committee that advises the Agency and the Department of Health.
Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition In 1994, the Committee on Medical Aspects of Food and Nutrition Policy (COMA) recommended reducing the average salt intake of the population from 9g to 6g a day, in its report Nutritional Aspects of Cardiovascular Disease. This recommendation was based on evidence of a link between high salt intake and high blood pressure (also called hypertension).
In 2003 the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN), in its report on Salt and Health, reviewed the evidence since 1994 to consider if COMA’s previous recommendation to reduce the salt intakes of the population was still valid.
SACN concluded that the evidence for a link between salt intake and blood pressure had increased since 1994. The current high levels of salt habitually consumed by the population raise the risk of high blood pressure, which increases the risk of stroke and premature death from cardiovascular diseases. SACN confirmed that the population as a whole would benefit from reducing their intake to 6g per day. SACN also set lower recommended maximum levels of salt intake for babies and children for the first time.
In his preface to the report, Chair of SACN Alan Jackson states: ‘Meeting these targets would be of major benefit to public health. Even a small reduction in salt intake could help to reduce the burden of high blood pressure on our population.’
The recommended maximum amounts of salt set for adults and children are achievable population goals, not ideal or optimum consumption levels.
Diet and blood pressureStudies have shown that the greatest reductions in blood pressure are observed with a diet that is low in salt, total fat and saturated fat, and rich in fruit, vegetables, and low-fat dairy foods.
The Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) trial (Appel et al, 1997) assessed the effects of dietary patterns on blood pressure. The results demonstrated that compared with a typical US diet, a diet rich in fruit, veg and low-fat dairy products (the DASH diet) significantly reduced average blood pressure by 5.5/3.0mmHg.
The DASH Sodium trial (Sacks et al, 2001) examined the combined effect of the DASH diet and reduced salt intake. The greatest reductions in blood pressure were observed with the DASH diet and low salt intake (3g) which reduced blood pressure by an average 8.9/4.5mmHg below the control diet (representing a typical US diet) at the high salt (9g) level.
The DASH Sodium trial also showed that reducing salt intake reduced average blood pressure levels of people eating the DASH diet or the control diet. The effects were observed in those with and without hypertension, in both sexes and across ethnic groups.
Maintaining a healthy weight, not consuming too much alcohol, and regular physical activity will also help to prevent and reduce high blood pressure.

1 comment:

Dick Hanneman said...

DASH is a great eating plan -- more fruits, veggies and dairy products. But adding salt reduction doesn't help much. Without reducing salt, hypertensives dropped systolic blood pressure by 11.4 mmHg; cutting salt by 60%, added only 0.1 mmHg to 11.5 mmHg and in six of the eight subgroups -- representing the vast majority of the population -- there was no significant relationship.

The real issue isn't blood pressure, however, it is the relationship of salt to health. Specifically, the question should be: will reducing dietary salt reduce the incidence of heart attacks or cardiovascular mortality. Unfortunately for the folks at FSA, the dozen-plus observational studies cannot identify a benefit. FSA touts a Finnish study where a large population salt decline was matched by impressive improvements in cardiovascular health and extended lifespan -- impressive, that is, until compared with the UK, the US or any neighbouring countries all of which fared even better -- and none of which reduced salt.

The UK's Cochrane Collaboration invented "evidence-based medicine." Let's put that discipline to use and conduct a controlled trial of the question of whether reducing salt confers a health benefit.

For more informatin, please see our website, http://www.saltinstitute.or/28.html or our related blog, http://www.saltinstitute.org/rss/health-other/.

Dick Hanneman
President
Salt Institute

 
Google